Value Stocks vs AI Trade: John Rogers Sees Opportunity

The Great Market Split: AI Hype Meets Everyday Bargains
Imagine walking into a busy market where everyone is crowding around a shiny new technology booth. Meanwhile, right next door, steady shops selling everyday necessities are almost empty, even though their prices are lower than ever.
That is roughly how veteran investor John Rogers describes the current stock market. As co-CEO and chief investment officer at Ariel Investments, Rogers focuses on value investing—finding quality companies that the broader market has temporarily overlooked.
While artificial intelligence enthusiasm has driven major market indexes to record heights, Rogers notes that many non-tech consumer brands are trading at quiet bargains. In fact, numerous well-known companies are selling at valuations below 10 times next year's expected earnings.
Record Highs and Echoes of the 2000 Tech Bubble
The stock market has seen incredible momentum powered by semiconductor and AI technology companies. Investors have poured capital into AI-linked stocks since late 2022, driving optimism around corporate earnings. This wave carried both the Dow Jones Industrial Average and the S&P 500 to record levels on August 4.
More recently, the S&P 500 closed above 7,800 for the first time on Tuesday, driven once again by strong performance in semiconductor shares. However, Rogers sees strong parallels between today's market setup and the environment that preceded the 2000 internet dot-com bubble collapse.
During the late 1990s, money rushed into internet startups while traditional, non-tech businesses lagged behind. But when the tech bubble eventually burst, smaller and less glamorous value stocks went on to outpace the broader market for several years. Rogers wonders if history might repeat itself once the current AI trade cools down.
Deepest Discounts in Decades
Speaking on CNBC's "Squawk Box" on Wednesday, Rogers explained that the valuation gap between high-flying tech stocks and traditional companies has widened to extraordinary levels.
He noted that he has not seen discounts this deep in 20 to 30 years. When asked why these solid companies are trading at such low valuation multiples, Rogers offered a simple explanation.
"They’re selling at bargains because they are not the sexy things to own." — John Rogers, Co-CEO of Ariel Investments
In his view, short-term investor preference for exciting growth stories has left everyday businesses trading at deep discounts relative to their historical earnings power.
Four Picks Built to Withstand AI Disruption
A key element of Rogers' investment strategy is finding businesses that artificial intelligence cannot easily disrupt. He points out that human experiences, physical recreation, and essential consumer staples remain immune to digital replacement. Rogers highlighted four specific companies that fit this thesis:
1. The J.M. Smucker Company (SJM)
J.M. Smucker is the consumer goods company behind iconic household brands like Jif peanut butter and Folgers coffee. Rogers points out that consumers will continue buying coffee and food staples regardless of advances in AI software.
Interestingly, Smucker's stock performance has quietly kept pace with major tech giants. Over the past six months, J.M. Smucker has risen nearly 26% (or roughly 25%). For comparison, AI semiconductor leader Nvidia gained about 28% over the same six-month window.
In addition, FactSet data shows that analysts' average price targets suggest a potential 21% upside for Smucker over the coming year. However, investors should keep in mind that stock prices fluctuate based on broader economic conditions, raw material costs, and market sentiment.
2. OneSpaWorld
OneSpaWorld operates health, wellness, and beauty spas aboard ocean cruise ships. The company's stock has gained approximately 11% so far this year.
According to FactSet, the average analyst price target for OneSpaWorld implies a 36% upside. Rogers highlights that physical wellness and vacation pampering are hands-on experiences that digital tools cannot replace.
3. Madison Square Garden Entertainment
Madison Square Garden Entertainment runs famous live venues, including Radio City Music Hall in New York. The company's shares have risen roughly 49% this year.
Rogers notes that demand for live entertainment, concerts, and iconic venue experiences remains strong because people naturally desire in-person social gatherings.
4. Sphere Entertainment
Sphere Entertainment operates the futuristic, immersive venue arena in Las Vegas. Its stock has gained more than 8% this year.
Like venue operators, Sphere provides immersive physical experiences that artificial intelligence software cannot duplicate online.
Market Concentration and Risk Factors
While tech shares have driven major market gains, Rogers cautions that index heavy weighting creates hidden risks for passive investors.
Technology companies currently account for roughly one-third of the entire S&P 500 index weight. Even more striking, the top 10 largest companies in the index hold nearly 40% of its total weight.
This heavy concentration means that broader index funds are strongly dependent on a small group of tech giants. If tech earnings weaken or sentiment shifts, concentrated index funds could face increased volatility.
Timing the Market Shift
While the valuation gap is wide, Rogers readily concedes that nobody knows exactly when an inflection point will occur. Turning points in market cycles are notoriously difficult to predict.
Value stocks can remain underpriced for extended periods, and tech momentum can persist longer than expected. Investors looking at traditional value stocks must carefully evaluate their individual financial goals, horizon, and risk tolerance.
As a standard reminder, past performance of financial assets or market sectors does not guarantee future results. Stock investments carry risks, including potential price declines, economic changes, and company-specific challenges.
Latest blog posts

Trump Meme Coin Dinner Seat Cost Falls to $518
The minimum threshold to qualify for President Donald Trump's meme coin dinner has plummeted from $55,000 to just $518 ahead of tonight's event.

Kalshi Faces Potential Nationwide Shutdown in NY Court Battle
Prediction market platform Kalshi faces a crucial court hearing in New York that could force a nationwide shutdown and liquidate user positions.

Chainflip Discloses $12M Exploitation Involving 122.9 BTC
Chainflip faced a $12 million exploit involving BTC, ETH, and stablecoins, offering a 10% bounty for the return of funds.