Coinkite CEO Faces Backlash Over Coldcard Bitcoin Theft Comments

A Controversial Statement Following a Massive Theft
The cryptocurrency community is reacting strongly to recent comments made by Rodolfo Novak (often known as NVK), the CEO and co-founder of Coinkite. Coinkite is the company behind the popular Coldcard hardware wallet, a tool widely used by Bitcoin holders to store their funds securely offline.
In a series of public statements, Novak defended his track record by highlighting his 18 years of work dedicated to Bitcoin adoption. However, he stirred significant backlash when he claimed that only about 0.17% of Coldcard users were affected by recent security incidents. These security flaws allowed attackers to drain more than $100 million worth of Bitcoin from unsuspecting device owners.
The Social Media Post That Sparked Outrage
The controversy deepened after Novak shared a post on X (formerly Twitter) stating that "Bitcoin won" and indicating that his time in the crypto spotlight might be coming to an end.
Bitcoin won. Industry tenure is done. Backseat from now…
He included a victory hand emoji alongside the statement. Shortly after posting, Novak set his X account to private. He did not clarify what he meant by taking a backseat or whether he intends to step down from his position as CEO of Coinkite. The post quickly drew sharp criticism from users who pointed out the massive losses suffered by Coldcard customers starting around July.
Breaking Down the "0.17%" Affected User Estimate
The debate intensified when an X user named secondbestdrew pushed back on Novak's posts.
Your industry tenure amounts to countless people losing a combined total of over 100mm dollars of Bitcoin. Great work 🙄
Novak replied to the user by writing, "Yes, it sucks," before adding that he estimated 0.2% of Coldcard users were impacted. In a follow-up reply, he refined that number down to roughly 0.17%. He explained that he arrived at this figure by reviewing loss reports, analyzing public blockchain data, and comparing them with Coinkite's internal hardware production metrics.
However, critics quickly pointed out major gaps in this calculation:
- Production numbers vs. unique owners: Production figures measure how many hardware devices were manufactured, not how many unique individuals own them. A single investor might buy multiple Coldcards for extra security.
- Unclear definitions: Novak did not clarify if "affected users" meant only those who had their funds stolen, or if it included everyone who created a wallet using the vulnerable firmware.
- Lack of official data: Coinkite declined to provide official loss estimates in August and has not published exact figures since. Their sales figures remain private.
In August, Coinkite informed Bloomberg that the privacy-centric design of Coldcard prevented the firm from verifying loss estimates compiled by independent third parties. Coinkite's official status page also notes that public records do not provide a complete model-by-model list of victims. Meanwhile, a detailed technical postmortem analyzing the exploit is still under preparation, even though the first thefts were reported back on July 30.
The Extent of the Losses: Over 1,830 BTCBTC+1.54% Stolen
While Coinkite has not released an official total, research firms have provided detailed assessments of the damage.
In September, Alex Thorn, Head of Firmwide Research at Galaxy, reported that approximately 1,830 BTC had been stolen across roughly 9,200 blockchain addresses. At the time of his report, those funds carried a market valuation close to $116 million.
Galaxy directly assisted some of the victims to analyze what happened. Of the 256 Coldcard victims who reached out to Galaxy, 245 of them controlled 2,585 separate addresses holding a total of 895 BTC. (Please note: Past performance of digital assets does not guarantee future results or asset stability).
Legal Challenges: Class Action Lawsuit Filed in Ontario
The fallout from the security vulnerability has now moved to the courtroom. In September, a proposed class action lawsuit was filed against Coinkite in Ontario, Canada.
The lead plaintiff in the case reported losing 1.229 BTC across seven addresses generated within a single wallet setup. The lawsuit seeks to represent anyone who purchased a Coldcard device directly from Coinkite for personal use, covering multiple device generations:
- Coldcard Mk2
- Coldcard Mk3
- Coldcard Mk4
- Coldcard Mk5
- Coldcard Q
Both Rodolfo Novak and Coinkite co-founder Peter Gray are explicitly named as defendants in the lawsuit. If the court certifies the case as a class action, Coinkite may be legally required to disclose exact sales numbers to identify all eligible claimants.
Privacy Features vs. User Tracking
The situation presents an interesting paradox for hardware wallet companies. Coinkite has historically prioritized user privacy by minimizing customer data retention. The company previously stated it does not store customer records.
Following the exploit, Coinkite sent warning emails to every email address it could reach through its online store and newsletter lists. However, because many privacy-conscious users avoid providing real personal data when purchasing hardware wallets, reaching every owner remains difficult.
To put Novak's 0.17% estimate into perspective, if Coinkite had manufactured 1 million devices, a 0.17% impact rate would equal roughly 1,700 affected users (assuming one device per user). For context, competitor Ledger claims to have sold over 8 million devices worldwide. Unlike Ledger, which supports thousands of different cryptocurrencies, Coldcard focuses exclusively on Bitcoin.
Reactions and Market Impact Across Hardware Manufacturers
Public reaction to Novak's comments has been largely critical. Many community members questioned the timing of his retirement posts, arguing that executive accountability is crucial when millions of dollars in user funds are lost.
An X user named m R_s At commented, "Shouldn't you be doing the opposite right now?" in response to Novak's announcement about taking a backseat. While some loyal supporters thanked Novak for his long-term contributions to the Bitcoin ecosystem, Novak dismissed several of his harsher critics as being "competitor's bots."
The ongoing crisis at Coinkite has reshaped consumer choices in the hardware wallet sector. Competing hardware manufacturers—including Trezor, OneKey, and BitBox—have seen a surge in sales as users reevaluate their self-custody setups and security models.
Latest blog posts

3 Altcoins Defy the Market Crash as Bitcoin Hits Two-Year Low
Bitcoin fell near $55,000 amidst market liquidations, but Pieverse, Venice Token, and Pearl managed to record notable weekly gains.

Shiba Inu Netflow Drops to 18B: Is Selling Pressure Easing?
Shiba Inu saw its exchange netflow drop sharply to 18 billion SHIB as selling pressure cools down, alongside a modest 1.51% price uptick.

Can Bitcoin's Proof-of-Work Stop AI Cyberattacks?
Former Space Force Director Major Jason Lowery proposes using Bitcoin's Proof-of-Work security mechanism to defend U.S. infrastructure against AI threats.